Expand Menu
Close Menu
Back
Gold Leaf Gilding
Home | What's Going On | Blog

Imitation Gold Leaf Vs. Real Gold Leaf

Gold leaf has long been a prized material in decorative architecture, known for its brilliant luster. There are two primary types of gold leaf used in gilding: real gold leaf and imitation gold leaf. Understanding the differences between these two materials, as well as their pros and cons, is essential for selecting the right one for your project.

What is Gold Leaf Made Of?

The composition of gold leaf varies depending on the type. Real gold leaf is crafted from genuine gold, and can be mixed with small amounts of silver and copper to achieve different shades and karat values. It is valued for its longevity and resistance to tarnishing. Imitation gold leaf, however, is made from a combination of metal alloys like brass, copper, or zinc. These materials mimic the appearance of real gold but are more susceptible to tarnishing and require additional protective coatings to maintain their look over time.

How is Gold Leaf Made?

Gold leaf is made through a meticulous process called goldbeating. It starts with melting and casting gold into a bar or strip, which is then rolled into a thin ribbon. This ribbon is cut into smaller squares that are placed between layers of special paper and hammered until they reach the desired thinness. Finally, the thin sheets are cut to size and packaged for use in various decorative applications. The process for making imitation gold leaf differs primarily in the materials used. Instead of gold, metal alloys such as brass, copper, or zinc are melted and cast into sheets. These sheets undergo a similar rolling and beating process but often require additional coatings to protect against tarnishing and to maintain their appearance over time.

What to Consider When Choosing Real Gold Leaf

There are two main factors to consider when choosing a gold leaf: its content/value and weight. Additionally, you should also consider the choice of adhesive size.

Gold Content

Gold content expresses the purity of the leaf and ranges from 6 karat to 24 karat, which is 100% gold. The degree to which the gold is mixed with silver or bronze will determine the karat value: silver will give a cooler tone and bronze a warmer tone. Gold content should be chosen in light of the project to be done, specifically whether the project is indoor or outdoor. All exterior projects should be gilded with gold leaf no less than 23.75 kt. Because gold is the noblest of metals, it is resistant to corrosion—the purer it is, the stronger it will resist rain, snow, sleet, and wind. Gold leaf of such value will maintain its integrity for 30+ years. Interior projects, since they are not subject to climate changes, can be gilded with gold leaf of less than 23 kt. Typically, interior gilding of architectural features is 22 karat gold. The 21-22 karat range is good for interiors and has been used for centuries because it is extremely durable. The gold leaf used for interiors, if alloyed with other metals, can actually make it more durable to withstand general wear and tear and cleaning.

Weight

Gold leaf is weighed in grams per 1,000 leaves. The heavier the gold leaf, the more resistant it is to the climate and environmental issues. For this reason, a substantially heavy leaf is required for all exterior gilding projects—domes, statues, weathervanes, ornament. Typically, 18-23 grams per 1,000 leaves is recommended for exterior projects. As a studio, we will only use 21 or 23 grams. Interior gilding projects, however, are considerably less vulnerable to climate and environmental issues and are therefore better suited to use a lighter leaf.

Adhesive Size

An important note when it comes to gilding and the adhesive size you use. For architectural oil gilding, the choice of adhesive size is crucial. Long size, or slow drying size, should be used for exterior applications due to its elasticity, as the extended drying time accommodates the expansion and contraction caused by changes in the climate condition. This flexibility ensures both the gold leaf and adhesive size are able to expand and contract with weather changes, maintaining the integrity of the gilding. In contrast, quick size, or short drying size, when used for exterior gilding, can result in a more brittle and less durable finish, potentially leading to a significant loss of gold leaf integrity after just one season, compared to over 30 years with the correct adhesive size.
John Canning & Co. has used authentic gold leaf to execute a number of projects pictured here including the San Francisco City Hall, the West Virginia State Capitol, the Prometheus Statue at Rockefeller Center, the Horace Bushnell Memorial Theatre, the War Memorial Opera House, and many others.

What to Consider When Choosing Imitation Gold Leaf

Imitation leaf, also called composition gold leaf, Dutch metal, or Dutch gold, gives the appearance of solid gold, despite the fact it does not contain any gold at all. It is composed of some combination of copper, zinc, and brass and is much less expensive than gold leaf, which is its primary drawing factor. When choosing a leaf, you'll want to consider a couple of factors. First, determine its material composition, whether it's made from a combination of brass, copper, or other metal alloys, as this impacts both its appearance and durability. Durability is another key factor: you might opt for imitation leaf which will have to be treated with protective coatings, to help delay tarnishing. Additionally, consider the intended application, such as indoor or outdoor use, which may require different levels of protection. Much like the low karat forms of genuine gold leaf, imitation gold can be more sensitive to climate and environmental issues and is therefore not recommended for exterior projects. It is often used indoors and its desirability comes from its inexpensive nature and the fact that it is easier to handle.
Imitation gold leaf gilding in progress at a private residence can be seen here.

Which is Better: Real Gold Leaf or Imitation Gold Leaf?

If it can be afforded, it is usually more beneficial to use authentic gold leaf for both appearance and durability. The aesthetic of authentic gold leaf is much more consistent, rich, and brilliant than imitation leaf. Authentic leaf is also more practical, since it will maintain its integrity for many years. Imitation leaf is subject to oxidation and tarnish and, even if sealed with a protective top coat, will often not last more than a few years before it acquires a green, dull haze. Circumstances aside, using authentic gold leaf for a gilding project is usually worth the investment. With that being said, imitation leaf can be ideal for certain projects, especially interior gilding projects containing a lot of surface area to be covered. Additionally, ceilings, cornices and other out of reach areas are more suitable for imitation gold, as these locations are less likely to be touched or subjected to wear and tear that could lead to tarnishing. The choice between real and imitation gold leaf hinges on your project's needs and budget. If you have any questions or a project you would like to discuss, please contact us.  
 
John Canning & Co. performed interior gilding projects at the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, WI as well as Radio City Music Hall where over 180,000 square feet were gilded with some type of metal leaf. The gilding at Radio City Music Hall consisted of both real and imitation leaf.
If you have any questions or a project you would like to discuss, please contact us.
Canning C

July 09, 2021

Featured Projects

San Francisco City Hall Gold Leaf Gilding Restoration

Our skilled restoration team used traditional gold leaf and gilding methods and materials to restor the exterior roof on San Francisco’s City Hall.

Close-up view of the West Virginia Capitol dome and its intricately detailed exterior gilding.

West Virginia State Capitol

Our team of artisans restored and fabricated metal elements then applied sizing and gold leaf to specified areas of the West Virginia State Capitol.

Rockefeller Center Gilding Feature

Prometheus Fountain Gold Leaf Restoration

We restored the Prometheus Statue, a National Historic Landmark located in Rockefeller Center using gold leaf gilding.

Interior of the Radio City Music Hall Lobby in New York City, New York featuring an ornate curved ceiling with gold leaf detailing, elegant red draperies, and classic hanging light fixtures.

Radio City Music Hall Restoration

We applied over 180,000 square feet of metal leaf and glazes in order to properly restore the 1932 historical golden interior of the Radio City Music Hall.

bushnell dome

Horace Bushnell Memorial Theater Restoration

John Canning & Co. restored and gilded the dome and cupola of the Bushnell Theater.

War Memorial Opera House Restoration

We carefully applied traditional gold-leaf gilding and glazes on 500,000 linear feet of historic architectural elements at the War Memorial Opera House.

John Canning & Co.'s Art of Exterior Gilding and Domes Resource
John Canning & Co. Resources

As a conservation studio and restoration contractor, our team of highly skilled craftsmen, artisans, and conservators are experienced in the use of traditional methods and materials. We understand the importance in sharing our expertise and knowledge in our field.

Check Out Our Art of Exterior Gilding & Domes Guide